ext_1620665: knight on horseback (Default)
[identity profile] scfrankles.livejournal.com posting in [community profile] sherlock60
This week we’re having a look at The Speckled Band. As usual, I’ve typed up a few thoughts to get the discussion going.

The events in question occurred in the early days of my association with Holmes, when we were sharing rooms as bachelors in Baker Street. …working as he did rather for the love of his art than for the acquirement of wealth… This is perhaps intriguing. What is Holmes’ financial situation? In STUD Stamford explicitly reports to Watson that Holmes needs someone to share the rooms at Baker Street because they are too expensive for him. Yet here, still in the relatively early days of his career, he’s not worrying about money. Holmes is a gentleman but that doesn’t necessarily mean there’s wealth in the family... Still, maybe some kind of modest private income..?

…I have reasons to know that there are widespread rumours as to the death of Dr. Grimesby Roylott which tend to make the matter even more terrible than the truth. Rumours even more terrible than “he murdered one stepdaughter via poisonous snake, and the snake killed him when he was attempting to murder the other”? I wonder what these rumours could have been. That Roylott committed suicide using the snake? Or perhaps that Miss Helen Stoner murdered her stepfather?

"Farintosh," said he. "Ah yes, I recall the case; it was concerned with an opal tiara…” Any thoughts on this case?

"When Dr. Roylott was in India he married my mother, Mrs. Stoner, the young widow of Major-General Stoner, of the Bengal Artillery. My sister Julia and I were twins, and we were only two years old at the time of my mother's re-marriage.” I wonder what the story is here. Mrs. Stoner had her own money, so surely there wouldn’t be a pressing need to remarry. Did she feel the need to give her children a father? Was it love? When I read this story I always imagine Major-General Stoner as being the complete opposite to Roylott, but perhaps Mrs. Stoner made the same mistake twice—maybe Roylott reminded her of her late husband.

And what about Helen Stoner’s feelings towards her stepfather? I would imagine if you’d had a stepfather since you were two, you’d think of him simply as your father—even if the man didn’t love you. But, of course, Roylott was in prison for a long time, and wouldn’t have been directly involved in her upbringing then. That would perhaps have broken any bond. We know from what Helen Stoner tells us that her mother died when Helen and Julia were about 24, soon after the family returned to England after Roylott’s release. But I’m not sure exactly how long ‘a long term of imprisonment’ would have been, and what age the children would have been when Roylott went into prison.

Again, I wonder about the now Mrs. Roylott waiting for her husband instead of taking the children back to England immediately. I suppose India was their home, but was she actively waiting for her husband to be released? Did she want to take him back, or did she feel she had no choice?

“A month ago, however, a dear friend, whom I have known for many years, has done me the honour to ask my hand in marriage.” I suppose in modern terms this is a case of two people ‘settling’ for each other. After all, Percy Armitage could have asked Helen to marry him years ago. I know Miss Stoner calls him a ‘dear friend’ and seems fond of him but he does appear to be a bit of a wash-out. Miss Stoner knows she can’t call on him to help her—she has to go to Holmes instead. I wonder does she go on to marry Mr. Armitage. I got the impression she was getting married primarily to escape the loneliness of her life with her stepfather.

Next Sunday, 17th August, we’ll be having a look at The Engineer’s Thumb. Hope you can join us then.
(will be screened)
(will be screened if not validated)
If you don't have an account you can create one now.
No Subject Icon Selected
More info about formatting

Loading anti-spam test...

If you are unable to use this captcha for any reason, please contact us by email at support@dreamwidth.org

Profile

sherlock60: (Default)
Sherlock Holmes: 60 for 60

July 2020

S M T W T F S
   1 234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031 

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 15th, 2025 06:52 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios